Justice requires that Alexandre Nardoni return to the closed regime

Since April this year, he was in the semi-open regime, where the detainee can leave the prison to work, returning only to sleep.
13/08/2019 13h45 - Updated 13/08/2019 17h42
Photo: reproduction

The Court of Sao Paulo ruled today that Alexandre Alves Nardoni, 41, convicted of killing daughter, go back to the closed regime, when the prisoner is reclusive full time. Since April this year, he was in the semi-open regime, where the detainee can leave the prison to work, returning only to sleep.

The decision comes five days after Nardoni leave prison by the temporary departure of Father's Day, Another benefit of semi-open regime. Through this progression sentence, the detainee may also lower a day of prison every three days worked and has the right to up to five temporary exits, up to seven days, during the year. With today's decision, Nardoni lose all these benefits.

The judges Luis Soares de Mello Neto, Euvaldo Chaib and Camilo Lellis, 4th Criminal Chamber, cassaram progression Nardoni unanimously. The application of regression, made by MP (public ministry), I had as an argument not to perform a more complex criminological examination.

The prosecutor Luis Marcelo Negrini said an appeal by MP asking him to return to the closed regime, against progression, subjected to the test Rorschach.

The Justice confirmed and understood that, for progression happen again, Nardoni is subjected to the test Rorschach, known as “Smudge Test”. It is a psychological evaluation that is made by interpreting drawings.

The rapporteur Luis Soares de Mello Neto argued that “yet it has fulfilled requirements for the temporal progression prison, It does not show enough incontrovertible, until here, complete social rehabilitation of sentenced. Or it becomes difficult, at this time, granting the benefit”.

Mello Neto wrote in his vote, still, that the examination of Rorschach just did not occur because a professional fit was not found. The rapporteur determined, urgently, the test.

Also according to the judge, the negative of the facts by Nardoni “brings elements that destabilize the fulfillment of subjective criteria. Hence whether the accused internally admits crime, but prefer not to outsource, or effectively understand it has not practiced the facts, or even if any social pathology is found present, only more complex examination may say”.

Last Thursday (8), the prisoner left the prison Tremembe, a 147 km from São Paulo, for the benefit of the temporary output Father's Day. He had progressed to the open regime at the end of April this year, By decision of Judge Sueli Oliveira Zeraik Armano, of Criminal Executions Court of Taubaté, city 140 km from the state capital.

Last Thursday (8), the prisoner left the prison Tremembe, a 147 km from São Paulo, for the benefit of the temporary output Father's Day. He had progressed to the open regime at the end of April this year, By decision of Judge Sueli Oliveira Zeraik Armano, of Criminal Executions Court of Taubaté, city 140 km from the state capital.

Alexander and Anna Carolina Jatoba, 35, They were convicted of the triple murder qualified Isabella Nardoni, 5, dead in 2008. In this ocasion, the jury found that the child was strangled and thrown from the sixth floor of the building where they lived the couple lived, in the north of the state capital. For good behavior after completing two-fifths of his sentence, Anna Carolina has benefited from the semi-open regime in August 2017.

Jailers of male penitentiary Tremembe say Nardoni is one of the most dedicated men to work and study within the prison. Among the services you have done, is the production of chairs, iron and wood, used in state schools in São Paulo. Local officials praise the good behavior his.

Source: UOL


*** If you are in favor of a totally free and impartial press, collaborate enjoying our page on Facebook and visiting often the AM POST.


Contact Terms of use